Wading Through the Murky Injury Waters to Provide a Roadmap for Handling Your Team's Injury Situations

We're in the stretch-run of the fantasy season, and the NFL rewarded us with...six teams on bye? Thank you, Roger Goodell. You're the best! Sprinkle in the ever-growing list of injured players, and some of us (me) are struggling to put lineups together. I think I'm starting myself in one league it's getting so bad!
It's Week 11, and this is where playoff spots are secured. Teams on the bubble are hoping their stars perform, while the top seeds are just hoping their stars stay healthy. No matter how stacked the teams appear on paper, one injury to the wrong guy can unravel even the strongest of teams. While I can't help prevent injuries, I can at least provide updates on these guys, who will be expected to step up to fill voids, and who some of my favorite last-minute waiver adds are. On top of this, AngleRanks provides users rankings across all positions that can help with pesky start/sit decisions, and we also have a weekly article series from @FFrealitycheck. That can be found below for those looking for additional start/sit debates:

With no article last week (apologies for that), there's no receipts to review. As always, I want to make it clear that I am no medical expert, and all opinions regarding injuries are speculative and not based on any medical background. For that, go to Dr. Ribu Thomas (@Ribu18 on X), who is the resident medical expert at AngleRanks.
Let's not delay any further and get to the content you came here for. As always, get out your flashlights, put on your favorite adventure hat, and tighten those bootstraps! It’s time to venture into the Injury Hayes!
Though the Patriots have a bye, there has been some worthwhile injury news that we need to cover before the team returns to play. First, we’ll start with quarterback Drake Maye. Drake exited in Week 10 against the Lions after fracturing his fibula. Per Adam Schefter, it won’t require surgery, but he is expected to miss some time. Tommy DeVito is slated to be the next man up to lead the offense, assuming they don’t bring anyone in.
In addition to Drake Maye being sidelined, A.J. Brown will also miss multiple weeks due to a hamstring injury, also reported by Adam Schefter. This injury is probably a blessing-in-disguise for fantasy owners. Brown is one of those guys whose name value makes him hard to bench, even if he is in the middle of a slump. A.J. hasn’t been 100% at any point this year, and when you add on a tough upcoming schedule and Tommy DeVito throwing passes, it was a pipe dream to expect meaningful production down the stretch. At least with the injury, there’s no questioning whether he needs to be in lineups.
With Brown out, Demario Douglas, Mack Hollins, and Efton Chism will hold down the receiver room. Tight ends Hunter Henry and Eli Raridon could also benefit by being a safety blanket for Devito.
TreVeyon Henderson is also on IR due to an illness, and I’d be surprised if we see him again this year. The backfield will remain a heavy dose of Rhamondre Stevenson with some Corey Kiner and Lan Larison mixed in. Until Henderson gets close to returning, this'll be the last time he's mentioned in this series.
Bottom Line
Until Drake Maye returns, avoid everyone on this offense except for Rhamondre Stevenson, at least until we see if Tommy Devito can magically produce competent QB play.
This is really only of note for superflex and dynasty leagues. Beck made his first NFL start last season, and is now slated to miss this week due to a back injury. Josh Johnson will be his replacement
Bottom Line
This impacts Trey McBride owners more than anything. I'm not really sure if Josh is a better option, but he's at least been around the league and is smart enough to feed his best guys....maybe? McBride is super talented, and his "bad weeks" are some tight ends good weeks. You still need to start him, just with tempered expectations. As for Josh Johnson, I'm not even sure he's worth starting in two-QB formats, let alone single-QB or superflex.
Kyler is set to miss another week with a hamstring injury. Even when he’s healthy, he’ll at best be the QB2 behind Kirk Cousins, and I’m not even sure that’s a guarantee. The Kyler Murray rehab experiment was a failure, and it’ll be Kirk’s offense in Minnesota as long as he’s healthy.
Bottom Line
There’s not much to say here. Kyler has lost the starting gig and possibly the backup spot. He’s beyond droppable in redraft, and can likely be dropped in shallow dynasty formats. In deeper formats, even backups have value, so I’d hang onto him unless you need the roster spot for a waiver claim.
K9 is set to miss this week’s game against the Arizona Cardinals as he continues to work through a groin injury. This will allegedly be the second-straight game Walker has missed, but I’m not sure I believe that. I think Walker is healthy, and he’s just wearing a #10 jersey and switched his last name to Johnson for some reason.
In all seriousness, rookie Emmett Johnson was astonishing in his first start of his career, popping off for 101 rushing yards on 22 carries, while contributing six receptions, 70 yards, and two touchdowns in the receiving game. Truly a sensational performance. He’ll look to provide an encore for managers this week against a feeble Cardinals' defense. The extra week off for Walker should allow him to be ready for a Week 12 showdown against the AFC-leading Buffalo Bills. However, is a committee on the horizon if Emmett shows out again?
Bottom Line
Fire up Emmett Johnson if you roster him. If you don’t and need a last minute fill-in at RB, it’s rough out there. Hopefully you were able to pick up Kaelon Black if he was available in your leagues. If not, you can pick up Kenny Gainwell or Justice Hill and hope for some receiving volume. With all the teams on a bye, depth is hard to come by this week.
Tyjae Spears has been dealing with a knee injury, and that injury has landed him on the IR. Early indications pointed to Spears having a chance to play after he logged a full practice Friday. Tony Pollard will continue to be the workhorse in this backfield.
Bottom Line
Spears has hardly been fantasy relevant this season and will now miss time until the fantasy playoffs start. If you're looking to roster Tony Pollard's handcuff, pick up either Julius Chestnut or Nick Singleton.
Wicks is set to miss his fourth straight game due to an ankle/foot injury. Even when he returns, I wouldn’t be surprised to see him take a backseat to Devonta Smith and Makai Lemon, assuming both are healthy. Lemon has performed adequately with both Smith and Wicks sidelined, and it’ll be interesting to see if the Eagles continue to utilize his talents now that Devonta Smith is back.
Bottom Line
Wicks is out again. Continue to fire up Lemon if you’ve got him. If you’re hurting at the position, guys like Ryan Flournoy, Chimere Dike, or Elic Ayomanor could be decent waiver wire flyers.
Managers were already going to be without Puka this week with the Rams being on bye. However, news dropped today that fantasy managers will be without Puka for the rest of the season as he is set to undergo MCL surgery. Per Sarah Barshop of ESPN.com, Puka is on track to miss a couple of months.
With Davante Adams and now Puka sitting on IR, the Rams’ receiving room is pretty barren. As the Rams prepare for a Week 12 Thanksgiving Eve matchup against Green Bay, it looks like Konata Mumpfield, Tutu Atwell, and rookie CJ Daniels will be the names to watch and see who takes the WR1 role in this offense.
Bottom Line
If you’re a Puka owner, this is undoubtedly a tough blow as we move towards the playoffs. If you’re pushing the chips in this season, you can probably still move him and get some productive pieces back, though you’ll likely be selling Puka at 80 cents on the dollar. Picking up one of the aforementioned Rams’ receivers while they’re on bye may get you slightly ahead of the curve, but good luck figuring out which guy is the one to roster.
Wan’Dale was put on IR and is set to miss the rest of the season with an ankle injury. He’s still worth a hold in dynasty, especially in deeper formats. Elic Ayomanor and Chimere Dike will get some more run with the offense in his absence. Ayomanor is my top add off waivers at the receiver position, as he’s already shown some rapport with Cam Ward. The Titans also have a juicy matchup against the Dallas Cowboys this week, so points could be plentiful.
Bottom Line
Hold in dynasty leagues. Look to pick up Elic Ayomanor if he’s available, with Chimere Dike being an ok consolation prize, especially if your league gives out points for return yardage.
Baker has been beat up all season, and somehow found a way to injure his foot on his bye week. Seriously, can we get this man some bubble wrap? Anyways, Baker’s status is up in the air for this week’s game against the Lions due to this new foot injury in addition with a previously injured thumb. Per Scott Smith of the Buccaneers’ official team site, he is “trending in the right direction” and looked good in Friday’s practice session. Should he sit, undrafted rookie Jaylon Daniels would run the offense.
Bottom Line
In superflex formats, you probably need to start him, but it's more of a need-based start than a want-based start. Baker has just been unreliable all year, and although he faces a gettable Lions’ secondary, it’s never easy playing in Ford Field as a visitor. Start him with tempered expectations in superflex, and bench in single-QB formats.
JCM still hasn’t been activated from Injured Reserve, but did log full practices Thursday and Friday. He’s hopeful to be ready to go for Monday night’s game, so managers will need to keep a close eye on this situation as he works his way back from a groin injury.
Relying on Monday night players who aren’t fully healthy is always a risk, with any last minute scratches potentially leaving unfillable holes in lineups. If you have Rachaad White, I can understand risking it and throwing JCM into lineups. At least in that scenario, White can be a pivot if JCM is unable to go. Should he sit, the aforementioned White and Austin Ekeler would handle snaps out of the backfield.
Bottom Line
I lean towards sitting JCM. It isn’t a question about the matchup against the Bengals or his ability; I just don’t want to be left with no options if he’s a scratch on Monday. Avoid unless you’re already rostering White or Ekeler, or you have no other options at running back.
Brooks was able to log three full days of practice after being stuck on IR since Week 3 with an abdomen injury. He’s questionable heading into Sunday and could be activated from IR as we get closer to gametime. However, given how successful Chuba Hubbard has been this year, I don’t see Brooks having a large role in his return. He’ll likely be used when Hubbard needs a breather, and I don't expect him see many opportunities unless Chuba were to sustain an injury. He’s nothing more than a potential handcuff going forward.
Bottom Line
Under no circumstances should he be in your lineups. As long as Chuba is healthy, this is his backfield. At best, he's an explosive option that would need to do something big with the few opportunities he may see.
Tate practiced in full on Friday and is on track to play after missing two games with a shoulder injury. Tate is returning at the perfect time. Not only did the Titans lose Wan’Dale Robinson for the year, creating a hole in the passing attack, but the Titans also face an extremely porous Cowboys’ defense in Week 11. If Tate is able to suit up, he should see plenty of high quality targets and could be in line for a very productive fantasy day. If he is unable to suit up, Ward will be chucking it primarily to Elic Ayomanor and Chimere Dike.
Bottom Line
The possible target share and matchup are too good to pass up on. If Tate is in, you have to play him. If he misses, make Ayomanor your top priority waiver pickup.
Ladd is questionable heading into Sunday due to a back injury. He was able to practice in limited fashion this week, so there is at least some chance he’s able to suit up. However, with how bad the Chargers’ passing attack has been and how beat up Ladd’s gotten all year, you should look for some other options. If he suits up, there’s no guarantee he finishes the game. And even if he finishes the game, there’s no guarantee Justin Herbert can get anything going through the air. I’d target the Titans’ receiving duo that I mentioned earlier before playing Ladd. Even Ja’Kobi Lane or Antonio Williams are guys that may still be on waivers who I trust more than Ladd.
Bottom Line
Unless you’re super thin at receiver, I’d bench Ladd. Scour the waiver wire for Elic Ayomanor, Chimere Dike, Ja’Kobi Lane, or Antonio Williams if you have to. I simply do not trust Ladd or the Chargers.
Pittman is listed as questionable heading into Sunday’s game against the Eagles, and there’s a chance he is activated from IR. Pittman hasn’t seen game-action since Week 3 due to a foot injury, and it’s unclear what his workload will be. Honestly, even if it is a “full workload”, that wasn’t amounting to much fantasy production before his injury. You can keep him stashed on benches until he provides a reason to slot him into lineups.
Bottom Line
Bench until he shows signs of life. See the list of names provided in the “Bottom Line” analysis for Ladd McConkey for other options.
Mike Evans remains questionable due to an Achilles injury, but is reportedly going to play, according to Mike Garafolo. This would be Mike’s first game back since Week 6, and the first since San Francisco acquired fellow wide receiver Keenan Allen.
I wouldn’t be surprised if San Francisco eases him back in, especially as they gear up for a deep playoff push. The uncertain workload in conjunction with an extremely difficult matchup against a stout Minnesota defense make it hard to justify rushing him back into fantasy lineups. If possible, I'd wait until next week to add him to lineups. I want to see how the offense looks with him and Keenan, and also just see the workload Evans gets fresh off injury.
Bottom Line
If you’re thin because of bye weeks, you may just have to throw Evans back in lineups. However, if you can find other options, I would until we see how Evans looks returning from his Achilles injury.
Brock left and returned to the field multiple times last week before ultimately missing the second half with an ankle injury. He’s questionable heading into the weekend, and it seems to be a true coinflip as to whether he plays. Managers should monitor this situation closely and be ready to pivot at any moment. If he sits, Michael Mayer would take over and be a possible safety net for rookie quarterback Fernando Mendoza.
Bottom Line
I got burned once by recommending to bench Brock when he was hurt, and I won’t take that risk again. He’s too talented to keep on the bench. A 50% healthy Brock is better than most tight ends at 100%. If he plays, put him in your lineup. If he misses, Michael Mayer would be an easy pivot. If Mayer is already rostered, the Bengals’ Mike Gesicki or Washington’s Chig Okonkwo could be usable options this week.
Despite leaving last week’s game with an ankle injury, Geno has been cleared to play in Week 11 and should start for the Jets against the Chargers. This is probably bigger news for Garrett Wilson or Adonai Mitchell owners than it is Geno owners. Unless you’re in a superflex format, there’s no reason to start Geno.
Bottom Line
Geno can be a desperation option in single-QB formats if your starter is on bye, but I’d still prefer to pick up Cam Ward or Tyler Shough in that scenario. He’s a sit for me unless there aren’t better options available. In superflex leagues, he is playable.
Everybody’s favorite Kyle is finally set to return for the Bears after missing the last five games with a toe injury. In the last few editions, I’ve recommended benching Monangai if he were to play. However, I think the Bears were just being cautious and wanted to give him the bye week to fully heal, so they didn’t rush him back. I expect him to be back to his regular workload and is someone I’m comfortable firing into my lineups, especially given the matchup against the Saints. It’s very plausible he finds the end zone, and during Bye-mageddon, that could be all you need to survive the week.
Bottom Line
I’m ready to get him back into lineups. After all, he’s My Guy, Our Guy, Monangai.
Devonta hasn’t played since Week 6 due to a hamstring injury, but he has said he’s 100% healthy and ready to go. He returns in a moderate matchup against the Steelers, but the biggest bug-a-boo is the QB play. Joe Milton is inconsistent at best, and even though he has a cannon for an arm that could potentially generate some explosive plays for Smitty, it is a wildly inaccurate cannon that could generate a high-target, low-catch day for Smith. Regardless, he immediately returns as the WR1 in an offense that is desperate for a spark. He’s a start in all lineups.
Bottom Line
Start him. It’ll be interesting to see how he and rookie wideout Makai Lemon play off each other now that Lemon has started to find his footing on an NFL field.
Waddle has cleared concussion protocol and enters the weekend with no injury designation. He’s been disappointing this season to say the least but gets an extremely juicy matchup against the Raiders this week. The Broncos’ offense has been a bit better over the last few weeks, and given the matchup, I expect that success to continue. Waddle is a risky start, but I’m ok starting him against a weak Vegas secondary.
Bottom Line
Waddle has become a matchup-dependent starter in my book, and this qualifies as a matchup that managers should try to exploit. It’s risky, but sometimes you just have to plug your nose and take the dive.
Kelce exited last week’s game due to an ankle/calf injury, but he carries no injury designation with him into the weekend. The Chiefs have a very soft matchup against the Cardinals this week, and I see no reason to keep Kelce out of lineups. Kelce once again figures to be a key cog in the passing attack, even with the arrival of Josh Downs.
Bottom Line
Start him.
Below is a recap of the players we’ve talked about and who I’ve recommended to start or sit, assuming health:
Starts: Baker Mayfield (only in superflex), Geno Smith (only in superflex), Kyle Monangai, Carnell Tate, Devonta Smith, Jaylen Waddle, Brock Bowers, Travis Kelce
Sits: Jacory Croskey-Merritt, Jonathon Brooks, Ladd McConkey, Michael Pittman, Mike Evans,
Already Out/On Bye: Carson Beck, Drake Maye, Kyler Murray, Kenneth Walker III, TreVeyon Henderson, Tyjae Spears, A.J. Brown, Dontayvion Wicks, Puka Nacua, Wan’Dale Robinson
QB: Cam Ward, Tyler Shough
RB: Austin Ekeler (if JCM is out), Justice Hill, Kaelon Black, Kenny Gainwell, Rachaad White
WR: Antonio Williams, Chimere Dike, Elic Ayomanor, Ja’Kobi Lane, Ryan Flournoy
TE: Chig Okonkwo, Michael Mayer, Mike Gesicki
For other waiver wire heroes, check out this week’s “Waiver Wire Angle" from AngleRanks' own @FantasyInstall below. Though some may be already rostered, it’ll offer additional names to check for in your leagues, outside of what I’ve already suggested here. Be sure to return to AngleRanks every Tuesday to get this article hot off the presses before your leagues waiver wire period

Injuries to our star players can derail even the strongest of fantasy teams. While we can’t prevent them, we can do our best to give ourselves multiple options to prepare for the worst case scenario. In fantasy, it is better to be proactive and not reactive. If you’re reacting after players are marked OUT, you’re likely going to be too late in acquiring the best possible replacements for your lineup. Be diligent: roster your handcuffs so you’re prepared for any situation, collect depth pieces throughout the year, and stay in the know by taking in all the amazing content found on angleranks.com.
May your players stay healthy and be showered with touchdowns! If you enjoyed this, be sure to follow @TheDynastyCafe on X for more fantasy related content. Also, feel free to reach out for any roster related questions as the season goes on!
Remember: injury situations are fluid and rapidly changing, so keep an eye out for any updates after this article is released.
Kyle Hayes
The Inside Angle Editor-In-Chief| Constant contrarian| probably hates your favorite RB darling| J'Mari Taylor Truther
View Expert Profile →Put this into your own rankings
Build a tier board, compare it to Expert Consensus, and export a clean graphic in minutes.
Start Building